Hotel du Vin Edinburgh

Sophistication in a superb spot in the city, with top-notch contemporary comforts and a dash of cosy Scottish charm.

This 2008 opening from one of the UK's best-loved small hotel groups occupies a plum spot near the castle in Edinburgh's World-Heritage-listed Old Town. As with all Hotel du Vin properties, it makes the most of a historic heritage, having been largely converted from a former poorhouse lunatic asylum. The result is as far from a lego-like new-build as possible. Instead, in its tall rooms and multi-level layout, the architecture cleverly mimics the steep, warren-like closes and higgledy-piggledy topography that characterise the neighbourhood.

The interior design, too, honours the historic and characterful, but with a contemporary twist. Look out for the vast chandelier made from suspended crystal glasses that shimmers over the lobby. There are classic leather armchairs, internal glass walls, a whisky snug, a nouveau Scottish bistro, and (unlike some of the more showy hotels that have recently opened in Edinburgh) just a smidgen of tastefully subdued tartan. A great example of contemporary Scottish style.

Highs

• The trademark Hotel du Vin comfort factor – great bathrooms and exceedingly comfortable beds go without saying
• The buzzy but relaxed bistro is a definite step up from your average city centre hotel restaurant, and delivers a superb breakfast buffet
• A truly excellent wine list, with more choice by the glass than usual
• Even in its early days (we stayed a month after it opened), service was excellent and attentive
• One of the best locations in Edinburgh – all the main sights are within easy reach on foot

Lows

• Although it may feel like an independent boutique property, this is a chain hotel
• The decor throughout is rather dark, with very muted hues in the bedrooms - making winter nights cosy, but a little oppressive in summer
• There’s no spa or pool, nor any on-site parking (and valet service is not cheap)